category menu

Diet Dukan’s Plan for High School: Discriminatory Or A Dietary Dare?

powered by Fotopedia

Discrimination Or A Health Push To Stay Lean?

January 2nd is the traditional day to start thinking about diets and getting into shape.  It was the perfect day for Dr. Dukan, the French nutritionist and author of the best-selling books on the Dukan diet to launch his idea on how to slow down obesity in French teenagers. He chose this date to send an open letter to French President Sarkozy promoting a unique way to gain extra points for French students taking the strenuous end of high school test, called le baccalauréat.

An Anti-Obesity Plan Or Coy Marketing Scheme?

The main nitty-gritty of Dukan’s plan is to encourage French teenagers not to pass the overweight limit of 25 BMI during their last two years of high school.  The goal is for the student to stay within the 18-25 BMI the baccalauréat candidate gains extra points toward their last score.  The subject would be weighed twice a year and those opting into the program would receive six hours of extra information on nutrition, cooking and exercise. Hmmm, one wonders if the information would be unbiased or focusing on Dukan’s food plan?  As Dukan proclaims as a measure to not discriminate, those outside the ideal range of 18-25 BMI but progressing towards this healthy range would also gain some points.

Is this scheme a marketing tool to promote Dukan’s name in the press, especially on the first week of January where diets are ‘à  la mode?’

Or could this be a positive way to encourage young adults to stay in a healthy weight?

Shout out your thoughts in the comment section. Même en français-! Je peut les traduire.
As the final note the French Education Minister found Mr. Dukan’s proposition surprising and added that le baccalauréat is about testing knowledge, not a health exam.  Very little chance this will be passing the exam.

Click here to calculate your own BMI and click on back to brightonyourhealth.

Best in Health for a New Year filled with Good Health, The Way You Want It!  Mary

, , , , ,

5 Responses to Diet Dukan’s Plan for High School: Discriminatory Or A Dietary Dare?

  1. Rafael Raymond February 7, 2012 at 16:50 #

    Very good information and hints. Looking onward to reduce a couple of bodyweight. I’ll deliver some feedback after i try this. Regards!

    • mbrighton February 8, 2012 at 09:39 #

      Hi Rafael, Thanks very much for your comment. Let us know how your weight loss goals are coming.

  2. Claire January 10, 2012 at 22:16 #

    I was scandalised by this proposition when I first heard it on the radio – I didn’t hear that it was Dukan suggesting it, (makes it all the more suspect) but I can see no relevance whatsoever with the (or any) school curriculum.
    I would be all for lessons on nutrition and healthy eating as an extra or an option, I think many kids these days would benefit, but to get extra points on your “bac” for dieting during your exams ??? No way, that is giving the wrong message to students who, especially in France, are already under a lot of pressure. I could well imagine certain students being desperate for extra points and taking the dieting too far.
    The baccalaureat system is by no means ideal (what education system is ?) but this would corrupt things even more.

    • mbrighton January 11, 2012 at 22:28 #

      Claire, Thanks so much for your comment. I appreciate your thought on “I could well imagine certain students being desperate for extra points and taking the dieting too far.” That is a valid point and for those readers who are not familiar with the baccalaureat; this exam is extremely strenuous and demanding. We could imagine on how far some students would go for these extra points!


  1. Suzanne Saxe-R, Ed.D - January 9, 2012

    RT @mbrighton66 Dukan’s French High School Plan: Discriminatory Or A Dietary Dare?: Dukan's plan to help French …

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge

Subscribe without commenting

free tracking