category menu

new year's resolutions

Men Vs. Women Weight Loss Battle: Whose Scale Wins?

This article is part of a series on weight loss using European approaches to losing weight and staying fit. If you would like to see the first article in the series, please consult here, “French and Italian Weight Loss Methods: Time.” This latest article looks at the differences between men and women and weight loss. The French and Italian men and women are just like the same gender species world-wide, over here in France, women complain how easy men can lose weight where (us) women must struggle just to lose a kilo. Is it true that men lose weight easier than women? Here is how women and men are different and how both sexes can have a win-win weight loss.

Are men’s bodies adapted to stay leaner and lose weight easier?

Sometimes I counsel couples who want to eat healthier and lose weight together. The problem (for the woman in the couple) is that the male often seems to lose weight faster and easier while the female struggles to keep up. So frustrating when you are trying to be on a disciplined eating track and you see your other half doing (perhaps) less efforts with greater rewards.
We are different, men and women. Different brains, different body parts, different body shapes and different body physiology. And isn’t this great? Because how boring would it be if we all resembled each other? And when you look at the process of reproduction, it wouldn’t work any different way.

In fact, it is these key differences in a man’s and woman’s physiology that makes it so that women (in general) hold weight in different places, hold onto body fat for pregnancy and lactation, hold a different type of fat (that is harder to get rid of), and crave different foods than men. And all these differences mean that women find it harder to lose weight compared to men, unless women stay on track over a longer period with their weight loss plan. Find a determined woman who focuses on losing weight, and over time her weight loss patterns even out with her other male half in the couple and there is no difference in weight loss rate and efficacy.

The key is to stick with it.

Key Differences in Men and Women’s Physiology

The reason that men lose weight faster or can stay leaner easier compared to women is mostly due to differences in body physiology.

Visceral Fat vs. Subcutaneous Fat

men and women difference in weight loss

Visceral fat, or intra-abdominal fat, is metabolically active fat that is located (often) in men in the abdominal (the stomach) area around organs. This fat is the easiest to get rid of, but is also the most dangerous type of fat for our health when compared to subcutaneous fat, which is located under the skin. Subcutaneous fat is often located in women in the buttocks, hips and thighs, and it is considered as the hardest fat to get rid of because it is there for a reason: reproduction and lactation.

Muscle Mass

Whether we like to admit it or not (me no!) men have greater ratio of muscle mass to fat compared to women. This is because of the male hormone testosterone. Women have more percentage of body fat compared to men, but this is normal: women get pregnant, give birth and lactate, all reasons that the female body’s physiology is ‘programmed’ to store fat, to help with the reproduction  process.

Muscle is more metabolically active than fat, by 5%-10%, so the more muscle to fat ratio, the more calories a person will burn. In this muscle area, men have the advantage (unless they are sedentary couch potatoes) and thus, with their higher muscle mass, men also respond faster to exercise and a quicker weight loss.

 

men and women difference in weight loss

Food Preferences

Meat or carbohydrates? In general, studies have shown that men prefer eating meat while women want to eat carbohydrates, fruits and veggies. The differences in food preferences may be somewhat due to hormone differences: with testosterone, men may need to eat more protein and iron-rich foods, and these food preferences may make a difference in men’s body weight and weight loss. Additionally, when men start to pay attention to their diet when trying to lose a few pounds, they may initially lose weight faster because they are (actually) changing their diet. Women, in general, usually pay careful attention (already) to what they are eating and going on a stricter diet doesn’t change their weight as much as as it does in their male counterparts.

Men prefer meat? Women love their carbs!?
men and women difference in weight loss

men and women difference in weight loss

Hormone Differences

Testosterone in men vs. Estrogen in women. Testosterone builds muscle, and estrogen plays a key role in a women’s reproduction process. The hormone estrogen increases fat stores, especially around the hip, thighs and buttocks (Oh, lucky us women!). This key reproductive hormone in women is one key reason we have more fat stores around the hard-to-lose fat areas in the hip, thighs and buttocks.

men and women difference in weight loss

Where fat stores accumulate

In men, fat stores usually accumulate in the middle abdominal area. In women, fat stores usually accumulate below the waist. When men are losing weight, the metabolically active visceral fat (intra-abdominal fat) is lost first. This is why you notice men’s weight loss faster than women’s weight loss-the body fat men are losing is right there in front of us-on the middle. As it disappears, it is more noticable to the eye. For women, that hard to remove subcutaneous fat is hiding under our skirts, dresses and is less well noticed for small amounts of weight loss, unless a women loses a large amount of weight.

men and women difference in weight loss

men and women difference in weight loss

Enzyme differences: LPL and HSL

LPL: Lipoprotein Lipase adds body fat and HSL: Hormone Sensitive Lipase breaks fat down.

The fat storage areas in men and women also differ because of enzymes differences. In women, the fat storage enzyme, LPL, lipoprotein lipase, is located and secreted from the fat cells in the hips and thighs, whereas in men LPL is secreted from the fat cells in the abdomen area. The role of the LPL enzyme is to lay down more fat. Women have 3 to 5 times more LPL in the lower body compared to their upper body.

HSL, or hormone sensitive lipase, is an enzyme whose job is to break down fat for the body’s use. In females, HSL is very slow in releasing fat from the hips and thighs, whereas in men, the HSL is high in the visceral fat area so that fat in this area is faster to breakdown.

men and women difference in weight loss

Insulin Response

A diet higher in refined foods, like white bread and other foods you see in this picture, increases insulin secretion and increases fat stores, especially in the abdominal area. For both men and women, a diet high in refined foods increases insulin and increases fat stores, especially in the abdominal area.

 

men and women difference in weight loss

Psychology: Emotions vs. Ego

In general, my experience with male and female clients, is that women, more than their male counterparts, tend to make some of their worse food choices based on emotions and emotional eating. Men lean towards having a bigger ego (this is what I have read!), and may not have the urge to indulge when they are having a bad day.

men and women difference in weight loss

men and women difference in weight loss

Good news is that perseverance pays off for both sexes

Here is the good news: after a period of a few months, men’s and women’s efforts both pay off and equalize on the mission to lose weight. For women, the focus on sticking to a weight loss plan for at least six months helps women catch up to men.

Yes, it is easier for men to drop a few pounds (and that is frustrating), but at least efforts are rewarded in both camps with continued long-term efforts.

And you women reading out there, if you want to catch up with your other half even faster, here are my suggestions (below) on how to do it.

Stick with your weight loss and fitness goals! It does pay off.

 

men and women difference in weight loss

How can men lose weight efficiently and rapidly?

Here are some men’s weight loss tips that work for men (and women too!)

  • Keep exercising: building muscle mass helps to burn more calories, stay metabolically efficient, and help with lowering visceral body fat.
  • Lower intake of refined foods to help decrease insulin response.
  • Increase intake of fruits and vegetables and eat less carbohydrates such as breads, rice and pasta.
  • Continue towards a long-term weight loss program, it is only after several months of dieting and exercise, where real weight loss habits are engrained into normal habits.

How women can catch up to men even faster on the men vs. women weight loss battle:

  • Weight training: building muscle mass is one key on losing weight faster. A weight loss plan should include a way to increase muscle mass thru aerobic exercise (running, walking, biking) and some weight lifting at home or at the gym. You don’t have to bench press, you can pick up two cans of tomatoes and pump it up!
  • End emotional eating and stick with a big ego: A emotion food and drink record can often open eyes on whether you are engaging in emotional eating or have some strong links to food that are not hunger related. By breaking these links, you are encouraging more eating based on hunger and not stress. Why not stick with a big ego?
  • Lower insulin response: Lower intake of refined carbohydrates. This is good advice for both men and women. Fresher and less refined foods means lower insulin response and resistence and less fat storage.
  • Don’t give up: It takes about 6 months to catch up with men’s faster rates of weight loss. Just keep going.

Hope you enjoyed this article on the weight loss war between men and women. I would greatly appreciate you sharing this article to those who may benefit from the information. If you would like to subscribe to our monthly newsletter and article updates (then you won’t miss the next article in the series) why not subscribe with us? Here is the button to do it:

subscribe to our newsletter

 

Warmly,

Mary

If you are looking for one to one counseling via Skype or telephone, I also counsel private clients. Contact me and I can send you a list of my services.

french weight loss methods

 

Share ThisPin on Pinterest5Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedIn0Share on Facebook15Share on Tumblr0Share on Reddit0Email this to someoneShare on Google+2

, , , , ,

14 Responses to Men Vs. Women Weight Loss Battle: Whose Scale Wins?

  1. Michael M Felix February 22, 2017 at 11:27 #

    We’ve all heard that men and women come from different planets. What may be really hard for a girl to understand about a guy is that they seem to lose weight much faster.
    At First. Simply, men have the advantage of the composition of their bodies. They have more lean muscle tissue than women.
    Men tend to gain in the stomach while women tend to gain weigh in a pear shape. The bad news for men is that belly fat is the unhealthiest. It’s linked to heart disease. That’s the bad news.
    In general, more women are responsible for meals than men. That means they face the temptations of shopping and preparing food. It’s easy to pick up an extra snack if you’re hungry and grocery shopping.

    Thanks for this sharing 🙂

  2. Grace Chao January 18, 2017 at 07:36 #

    Hi
    That is a great article, I was in need of a weight loss diet tips and encountered your blog.I have access fat over thighs and I want to get rid of it. This was very informative.I am going to implement your ideas and hopefully I will achieve what I want.
    Thank you 🙂 🙂 🙂

  3. Wanicleide January 14, 2017 at 19:09 #

    thanks a lot for all these information… will help me on my project 2017!! new body!

  4. Tim Johnson January 11, 2017 at 14:01 #

    Great stuff Mary! We are all different, so why force one unique recipes for all?
    Keep the good work.
    Tim Johnson recently posted..The Army Diet Explained: Benefits & Results

  5. Jesse Lee December 14, 2016 at 02:36 #

    Great publication, I think that testosterone is the “great guilt” but women behavior talks louder. In the end it’s difficult for everybody.

    thanks for sharing, please also check mine.


    http://belezasaude.org/turbo-slim-funciona/

  6. Alexander - Anabolic Health September 22, 2016 at 23:11 #

    Since testosterone naturally helps burn fat and maintain less body fat, men indeed have it easier then women, but also women is supposed to be curvy compared to men!

  7. Jason Sather May 28, 2016 at 16:02 #

    This is great! My girlfriend and I are always jabbing each other back and forth on who has it easier when it comes to losing weight. Very cool article!

  8. Stephany Walker March 26, 2016 at 03:29 #

    An article very well explained on slimming men and women really are true men find it easier to lose weight because they have already been made to have more lean mass, now we women need more fats mainly because we have the pregnancy as one of the main reasons … Thank you for sharing

  9. Sylvia March 7, 2016 at 11:25 #

    Hey, great share…..

    I really loved this post. It consist of lot of valuable information that can actually help people to lose weight. Understanding the fundamentals of fat accumulation in men and women can really make it easy to lose weight as it helps in providing sort of guideline of do’s and dont’s to all the men and ladies.

    Thanks for sharing this informative post. I am also on my weight loss journey. I think your article is definitely gonna help me out. I will surely share it with my friends as well.

    Stay fit and healthy!!
    Cheers!!

  10. Wayne Taylor December 26, 2015 at 04:20 #

    Great post,

    I am 58 years young & have always had a weight problems (for the last 20+years at least 100 pounds overweight).
    I stumbled on a successful weight loss journey purely by accident & by necessity.
    In March 2015 I was diagnosed with Gluten intolerance,I found out at the diagnosis that I had been living with this condition also for the last 20-30 years without being aware of same.
    When I was told what I could eat & what I couldn’t eat..it hit me like a bolt of lightning!!!!
    Basically there was very little I could eat,because being gluten intolerant.means if you eat/drink anything with traces of wheat,rye,barley or oats you become quite sick,with side effects like stomach ache/bloat,constipation lethargy & importantly small intestine damage.
    So as I discovered we live in a world of wheat lovers,everything seems to trace back to wheat eg,bread,cake,bagles,pasta,pastries,spagetti,cookies,biscuits,all fast foods as they are usually crumbed…I could go on and on,plus if you like a drink,no beer,whiskey,bourbon,

    So I was left with reinventing my whole lifestyle,I had to formulate a new diet..I thought I would just die without the sbove…but in adversity you get strong!!

    So I based my new diet as plant based,no red meat.just chicken & fish and made my own bread with rice & corn flower.

    Believe me the weight just fell off me,100 pounds was easy to shed in 9 months

    My point to this story,is that when one is forced to make changes a diet,you suddenly discover the vitality & weight control you obtain without eating grains & red meat

    Red meat stays in your system too long and creates problems & we as humans wern’t meant to eat grains as they cause problems to our immune & digestive system.
    Wayne Taylor recently posted..Five Healthy Foods That Make You Feel Great

  11. Isabella Alves March 28, 2015 at 20:24 #

    That’s really the reality .. I have a hard time losing weight and your tips brought the information I needed! I will share your post now! thank you!

    • mbrighton March 28, 2015 at 20:35 #

      Merci !!! Thank you. Very happy the article helped.

  12. Atlas Mens Health December 17, 2014 at 20:46 #

    This is really interesting and makes sense. My wife always gets irritated at me because I tend to lose weight off of diets faster than she does and now I can explain why. This is a very cool article thanks for sharing.

  13. EA-The Spicy RD October 1, 2014 at 17:54 #

    Really great post Mary, and lots of great information to share! It is indeed the big question many of my clients have-“Why does my husband/boyfriend lose weight so easily, while I struggle…” I will definitely share your post!

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge

Subscribe without commenting

free tracking